I ran to the dollar store and picked up a few things:
Red & green disco-like ball necklaces
Gummy Rudolph noses
Then I printed out the pdf from Tatertots and Jello to make it easier for the neighbors and threw in some yarn "snow balls" that I was making for my daughter's Kindergarten class, threw them in a lunch sack and we were ready to go.
The girls had an absolute ball sneaking over to our neighbors houses after it got dark and dropping off their goodies.